I researched Providence and it goes with the story because it means divine guidence or care, and in Providence Charlotte is guided to go back to the ship and be the captain. I also researched the word benevolent and that goes to the story because It means having the desire to do good, and the street is called benevolent I think because her family what her to do good things to become a nice young lady. At the end of the story I was surprised that Charlotte decided to leave and go sail to great places.

Charlote and Zachariah piece together that Captain Jaggery was the only one other than Zachariah and Mr. Hollybrass that was on deck. Also Zachariah said that he didn't do it, and of course Mr. Hollybrass didn't kill himself. All those facts lead up to be that Jaggery should have been the one to kill Mr. Hollybrass. Don't lie Captain Jaggery!!!!!!!!

Captian Jaggery uses Charlotte's identity to build his case by not letting her talk during the trial, and by interrupting her to make her give up, and to come to his side. Captain Jaggery also accused her of dropping the dirk and killing Mr. Hollybrass. He also said that since Mr. Hollybrass was holding her handkerchief she had to have done it. In the book it said that Charlotte the whole time was on the mast cutting the sails, so that meant that she couldn't have done it.

Charlotte's realizes and learns that justice is going to be Captain Jaggery putting her on trial to see if the crew members really do trust her and are her friends. She believes it's Zachariah because he and Jaggery were the only ones who know where she had kept her dirk, and also where her luggage was. I agree with Charlotte because Zachariah could have snook out of the brig and took the knife, and preteneded to be someone and murdered Mr. Hollybrass. Otherwise it might have been the Captain.

Charlotte should say that they have no proof, and that Hollybrass could have killed himself to make Charlotte be committed to murder. Who knows Hollybrass could have took Charlotte's handkerchief and pretended to kill himself. The captain has outsmarted her by committing her for killing Hollybrass and putting her on trail.

For my next post I will list problems and if solutions.

• All the porters run off of the fear of Captain Jaggery; Charlotte is brave and hops on board.
• Charlotte has to either befriend Captian Jaggery, or Zachariah; Charlotte chooses Captain Jaggery
• Charlotte finds out about the round robin, she either tells or she doesn't; she tells the captian about the plan.
• Charlotte tries to save Zachariah from his whipping; she whipes Captain in the face.
• Charlotte tries to be nice and friendly with the crew; they let her bee part of the crew, but the captain calls her Mister Doyle instead of Miss Doyle.
• The captain makes her work hard; her hands get rough and sore.

Charlotte in some ways is a threat to Captain Jaggery, by joining the crew and try to overpower him in some ways. Another is that if the captain is bad then Jaggery might not get payed, so the captain needs to be careful of maybe what Charlotte would tell her father, or write in her journal. She reminds him by telling him that she can do what she wants to do, and when she signs on to be a crew member. The captain wants to remind her tell she is in the captain's orders, and she can work hard.

In chapter eleven if Charlotte wrote a letter to the crew in this point of the story she might say, that she is sorry for telling the Captain about there plan and the round robin. I thought Charlotte felt guilty for not choosing someone because, then Zachariah might have not been killed. Charlotte might regret accidentally whipping Captain Jaggery in the face. This is the letter Charlotte might write to the crew.

Dear Crew Members,

I feel so terribly sorry for telling the Captain about the round robin then maybe Cranick and Zachariah might not have been dead. I hope your not mad for trying to save Zachariah. I'm happy and mad for hitting Captain Jaggery, but I am still deciding otherwise. I hope you accept my apology.

Sincerely,Charlotte Doyle